Everything About Method Overloading Vs Method Overriding

In a previous article Everything About ClassNotFoundException Vs NoClassDefFoundError, I have explained ClassNotFoundException and NoClassDefFoundError in details and also discussed their differences and how to avoid them. If you have not read it, please go ahead and give it a look.

Similar to that here in this article, we will look into one more core concept of Java which is method overloading and overriding. As soon as we start learning Java we get introduced to them and their contracts which are pretty simple to understand but sometimes programmers get confused between them or they do not know either it is a correct overload/override because of the different rules.

Here we will discuss What is method overloading and overriding, What contract one must follow to correctly overload or override a method, What are the different rules of method overloading and overriding and what are the differences between them.

Method Overloading

Method overloading means providing two separate methods in a class with the same name but different arguments while method return type may or may not be different which allows us to reuse the same method name.

And this becomes very handy for the consumer of our class, he can pass different types of parameters to the same method (in his eyes but actually they are different) and get the response according to his input e.g. System.out.println() method accepts all types of objects primitive types and print them but in reality there several println present in the PrintStream class.

public class PrintStream {

    // other methods

    public void println() { /*code*/ }
    public void println(boolean x) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(char x) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(int x) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(long x) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(float x) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(double x) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(char x[]) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(String x) { /*code*/ }
    public void println(Object x) { /*code*/ }
    
    // other methods
}

While overloading has nothing to deal with polymorphism but Java programmers also refer method overloading as Compile Time Polymorphism because which method is going to get called will be decided at compile time only.

In the case of method overloading compiler decides which method is going to get called based on the reference on which it is getting called and the method name, return type, and argument list.

class Human {
    public String speak() { return "Hello"; }

    // Valid overload of speak
    public String speak(String language) {
        if (language.equals("Hindi")) return "Namaste";
        else return "Hello";
    }

    public long calculate(int a, long b) { return a + b; }

    // However nobody should do it but Valid overload of calculate
    // by just changing sequence of arguments
    public long calculate(long b, int a) { return a + b; }
}

Method Overloading Rules

There are some rules which we need to follow to overload a method and some of them are mandatory while some are optional.

Two methods will be treated as Overloaded if both follows below mandatory rule.

• Both must have same method name
• Both must have different argument lists

And if both methods follow above mandatory rules then they may or may not

• Have different return types
• Have different access modifiers
• Throw different checked or unchecked exceptions

Usually, method overloading happens inside a single class but a method can also be treated as overloaded in the subclass of that class because subclass inherits one version of the method from the parent class and then can have another overloaded version in its class definition.

Method Overriding

Method Overriding means defining a method in the child class which is already defined in the parent class with same method signature i.e same name, arguments and return type (after Java 5 you can also use a covariant type as return type).

Whenever we extend a super class in a child class, child class automatically gets all the methods defined in the super and we call them derived methods. But in some cases we do not want some derived methods to work in a manner which they are doing in the parent then we can override those methods in child class e.g. we always override equals, hashCode and toString from Object class, you can read more on Why can't we override clone() method from Object class.

In case of abstract methods either from a parent abstract class or interface we do not have any option we need implement or in other words override all the abstract methods.

Method overriding is also known as Runtime Polymorphism and Dynamic Method Dispatch because which method is going to get called is decided at runtime by JVM.

abstract class Mammal {
    // Well might speak something
    public String speak() { return "ohlllalalalalalaoaoaoa"; }
}

class Cat extends Mammal {
    @Override
    public String speak() { return "Meow"; }
}

class Human extends Mammal {
    @Override
    public String speak() { return "Hello"; }
}

Using @Override annotation on the overridden methods is not necessary but using it will tell you if you are not obeying overriding rules. 

Mammal mammal = new Cat();
System.out.println(mammal.speak()); // Will print Meow

At the line mammal.speak() compiler says the speak() method of reference type Mammal is getting called, so for compiler this call is Mammal.speak().

But at the execution time JVM knows clearly that mammal reference is holding the reference of object of Cat, so for JVM this call is Cat.speak(). You can read more on How Does JVM Handle Method Overloading and Overriding Internally.

Method Overriding Rules

Similar to method overloading we also have some mandatory and some optional rules which we need to follow to override a method.

With respect to the method it overrides, the overriding method must follow below mandatory rule.

• It must have same method name
• Must have same arguments.
• Must have the same return type, from Java 5 the return type can also be a subclass (Subclass is a covariant type to its parent).
• Must not have a more restrictive access modifier (if parent --> protected then child --> private is not allowed).
• Must not throw new or broader checked exceptions.

And if both overriding methods follow above mandatory rules then it

• May have a less restrictive access modifier (if parent --> protected then child --> public is allowed).
• May throw fewer or narrower checked exceptions or any unchecked exception.

Apart from above rules there are also some facts

• Only inherited methods can be overridden, Means methods can be overridden in child class only.
• Constructors and private methods are not inherited so can not be overridden.
• Abstract methods must be overridden by the first concrete (non-abstract) subclass.
• final methods cannot be overridden.
• A subclass can use super.overridden_method() to call the superclass version of an overridden method.

Difference Between Method Overloading and Method Overriding

You can find complete code on this Github Repository and please feel free to provide your valuable feedback.